On Stephen Walt's... whatever
















I started my day reading Justin Raimondo's report that Porfessor Stephen Walt was "kicked out" of his job as Harvard's Kennedy School dean in retaliation for co-authoring the controversial Israel Lobby paper on which I've written earlier. And the day ended with Steve Clemons reporting that the Dean of the Kennedy School has stated that there was no connection between Walt's stepping down as academic dean "at the natural end" of his term and the Israel Lobby paper (although Steve seems not to be entirely convinced and is waiting for direct communication from Walt). In between I received an email from someone "close" to the controversy who insisted that Walt wasn't fired. Well... whatever really happaned it seems to me that the assault on Walt and his co-author Mearsheimer are bound to produce a "chilling effect" on anyone who wants to conduct a serious and honest debate on U.S. policy in the Middle East. While I had some reservations over several of the points raised in their paper (and I certainly don't regard Mearsheimer and Walt as "victims"), I think that much of the attack on them wasn't motivated by the concern over the "quality of their research" and had very little to do with the merit of the arguments. Insetad, the attack reflected a concern that the views expressed by these two renowned scholars would provide a certain legitimacy, if not respectability to criticism of the Israel Lobby. So even if Walt wasn't really "fired," his bashers have achieved their goal. Let me conclude this short post with the wise words of Steve Sailer:
In any case, doesn't this entire controversy where the Israel Lobby en masse furiously denounces these two scholars for pointing out the existence of the Israel Lobby remind you of that scene in "The Wizard of Oz" where the Wizard shouts, "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain"?

Comments

Anonymous said…
You can be sure of one thing; Professors Walt and Meirsheimer are certain to have the chamberpots emptied over them in a determined attempt to impugn their names and reputations.

Simply to write the words, "Israel Lobby" (much less to actually discuss it as they do) is to lay one's self open to furious attack.

This will not be conducted openly of course. Max Boot's syndicated column this week is singularly inane, although the ineffable Mr. Boot does manage to impute anti-Semitism (surprise!) to the authors without stating this plainly. (And why does he quail at doing so? After all, under the legal standard for 'genuine malice' in U.S. courts, it is almost impossible for anyone suing for libel to win. This faint-heartedness from the same Boot who--himself from ease and safety--exhorts our troops to show heroic valor against the evil Saracen.)

No, the real work of sliming people goes on in the war rooms and on the blogs ("Little Green Footballs", anyone?) where scurrilous stuff gets into public (and private) discourse the way sewage leaks into a drinking well.

While I agree with Professor Hadar that there are some mistakes the authors should have avoided (for example--Israeli public opinion is anything but the monolith that the authors mistakenly imply--as the recent election there should show); nevertheless, their piece is a landmark discussion of this issue. Whatever offal gets thrown at them now, Miersheimer and Walt have breached the taboo against open discussion of the lobby and it's activities in a way that can never be undone.
Kally RTose said…
Eliz Keto cutting out snacks etc. You should also choose a weight loss program that encourages gradual weight loss rather than immediate weight loss. By doing this, the weight you lose is more likely
Unknown said…
LNG Active Male Enhancement The "winners" will surely increase stamina, libido, as well as the size and girth of a man's erection. Despite what doubters say about such claims, if you look into
Unknown said…
lng active male enhancement reviews the hormone androsterone. Pheromones are simply hormones that are released into the air by evaporating sweat being breathed in by the potential partner
Unknown said…
Keto Jolt be sucked in by the promise of losing a certain number of pounds in a specific time period - everyone loses weight at a different rate, and the only way to guarantee you will lose any weight
Unknown said…
Wonder Full Keto Let's talk body basics. We eat to stay alive. When we eat extra it becomes fat. When we don't eat enough to sustain ourselves, the fat is burned off to use up what we've stored. It's that simple. All mammals have this
Endy Mist said…
Slim x genie keto As a physician who has successfully helped 50 patients lose a total of 2000 pounds, or an average of 40 pounds each, in a 5 month period, I can tell you that these myths only get in the way of healthy and safe rapid weight loss. And NO! These patients did NOT have gastric bypasses or lap bands! They used their bodies' natural weight loss tactics to succeed.
Judi Dench said…
Keto 10x than is needed for a full day), you WILL BURN FAT to make up for energy that you don't have coming
Endy Mist said…
Control X Keto However, if you skip in from food. So skipping breakfast, during a lower calorie intake period, allows you to burn excess to survive their lack of adequate nutrients.
Judi Dench said…
Mega Keto Diet God and evolution also designed us to HEALTHILY use up this fat store when we don't have enough food. Fasting is how we starvation. If it was unhealthy, the system wouldn't exist as it came to be through evolution and nature. The fittest survive, and those with fat storage systems survived longer when there is no food.
Illeana Menon said…
Whatever your skin type, there is a solution in nature for it and you may need to make several trial and error efforts before you find the homemade skincare tips that work for you and your skin. FairyMines
Annie Jhons said…
So, the social engineers at SIECUS have got this sexual orientation all figured out huh? On their website SIECUS and the other champions of postmodern sexual redefining seem very sure that sexual orientation is explicitly unchangeable. Family of Thakurganj full movie download
Illeana Menon said…
Valley Fair Amusement Park offers 75 rides and attractions for you to enjoy. There are 8 roller coasters with various thrills and loops. Kabir Singh Full Movie Download
Illeana Menon said…
Vegan e-books are created by professional vegan chefs, are proofread, and the recipes within are absolutely amazing! Trendy Mumi

Popular posts from this blog

When will Israel attack Iran?